Get it by December 22nd!* Details >
 
 
 

Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 of 7 | Next


By Dee

from Tucson, AZ

Verified

Nice color, but flakes off

 
2.0

PROS

CONS

BEST USES

Comments:

I bought it because of the color (plum). I was disappointed that by the end of the day it ended up under my eyes, giving me the effect of dark circles.


By dlfoch

from San Luis Obispo, CA

Disappointed

 
1.0

PROS

CONS

  • Difficult To Apply

BEST USES

Comments:

I was hoping I'd be one of the users of this new eyeliner who like it, but I'm afraid I don't. I miss the smooth application of the former eyeliner, and the fact that it didn't ever need sharpening. I hope the DHC people are reading these reviews!


By j9

from panguitch

Worst Pencil I have used

 
1.0

PROS

CONS

  • Difficult To Apply

BEST USES

Comments:

I loved the eye liner before they came out with this pencil. I never could get it give color on my eyes, I felt I was having to push way too hard around my eyes. I am so glad to see they are discontinuing it. I hope they bring the old one back, PLEASE


By Diane

from Kansas

Not as good

 
2.0

PROS

  • Long-Lasting

CONS

  • Difficult To Apply

BEST USES

  • Everyday

Comments:

Not as easy to apply as the recently discontinued Perfect Pro Liner. Always needs to be sharpened. Can't just keep it in my purse because it always needs sharpening. Doesn't last long. Ordering another just to have on hand until I find one I like.


By Janice the Balloon Lady

from Denver, CO

Verified

Just O.K.

 
2.0

PROS

  • Bold Color

CONS

  • Fades Throughout Day

BEST USES

  • Everyday

Comments:

I am still looking for the perfect eyeliner pencil. This goes on nicely, but it fades and runs after a while. I live in a dry climate and thought it would work well for me, but after a couple of hours it bleeds along the tiny wrinkles under my lower eyeliner.


Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 of 7 | Next

Review Search by Review Search powered by SLI Systems and Review Search powered by Power Reviews